Fallout Expands from Ending MCAS Grad Requirements

Image

The 2024 ballot initiative vote that gutted MCAS, the state's model program for ensuring student success and educator accountability. continues to have major repercussions.       

 A new report, released on Monday by the Voices for Academic Equity Coalition, finds that — in the absence of a common statewide graduation requirement — Massachusetts districts are using low, uneven, and inequitable standards to determine whether students are ready to graduate from high school.

The report — titled Ready or Not? Are Today's Diplomas Setting up Students for Success? — analyzed the grading and graduation policies of the more than 300 school districts in Massachusetts. Following the removal of MCAS as a graduation requirement in November 2024, each district became responsible for determining their own competency standards, with no statewide requirement in place.

“A Massachusetts high school diploma can mean dramatically different things depending on which district issued it,” the report states. “The variation is not random: it maps onto race, income, and geography in patterns that should concern state policymakers — and anyone who cares about every Massachusetts student being prepared for post-secondary success.”

There are four key findings from the analysis:

  • A low bar. The state law still requires high school diplomas to represent that students have “demonstrated mastery of a common core of skills, competencies, and knowledge,” yet the overwhelming majority (73%) of districts set their failing grades at 65% or lower; some even allow students to pass with a grade as low as 50%.
  • No common measure of mastery. Without a state role, districts assess “mastery” of a subject in myriad ways, from passing a final exam, completing a portfolio or capstone project, or “an equivalent measure,” determined by the district. There is no statewide objective measure or independent verification that students have actually mastered a subject.
  • High graduation rates, but low proficiency. Graduation rates and rates of a student’s actual academic proficiency are diverging sharply. When comparing 2025 graduation rates (the most recent available) and 2026 MCAS proficiency rates across the Commonwealth’s 26 “Gateway Cities” — home to the largest populations of students of color, multilingual learners, and low-income families — the report found a 28- to 47-point gap between the percentage of students scoring “Not Meeting Expectations” on MCAS that does not align with the percentage of students graduating.
  • Inequity across districts. Even neighboring towns’ diplomas are not equivalent. For example, in Lawrence, 47% of students did not meet expectations in English Language Arts (ELA), while next door in Andover, just 6% of students did not reach that level. It’s critical to note that these disparities in scores translate into earnings. Ten years after graduating from high school, graduates from neighboring towns have starkly different earning potential, with those from higher performing towns earning as much as $30K more per year than their peers in lower performing towns.

“Every family in Massachusetts deserves to know just what their child’s diploma means,” said Mary Tamer, Executive Director of MassPotential, a nonprofit education organization and convener of the Coalition. “Currently, a student in one district can pass with a 50, while a student in another district needs a 65. Neither number can be trusted to tell parents if their child is actually prepared for college or a future career.”

Through this report, the Voices for Academic Equity Coalition is urging state leaders to make necessary changes, presenting a three-point plan of recommendations.

  • First, setting a statewide course passing score so every family knows their children are “demonstrating mastery” as intended by state law. The state Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) could implement this now, without the need to pass a new law.
  • Second, the state must ensure diplomas include a meaningful, objective check that demonstrates students’ readiness for their next step. The Governor’s K-12 Statewide Graduation Council report recommends end-of-course assessments (EOCs), which are created, administered, and graded by the state, establishing a common, reliable and valid measure.
  • Finally, a diploma’s value should not be based on one’s zip code. Two-thirds of young people in Massachusetts think there should be a statewide graduation requirement for all high schoolers, with 67% believing lowering standards will make graduates less prepared for the future. State leaders owe every child, in every district, a quality education — and the current system cannot fulfill that promise.

About the brief

Published by the Voices for Academic Equity Coalition. Data: DESE GEM$ CD Policy and Local Graduation Requirements submissions, 2025 (300+ districts); DESE 2025 graduation rates (updated March 2026); DESE 2026 MCAS results. Produced by Erin Cooley, Jill Norton, and Mary Tamer, MassPotential. This work was made possible through the support of the Barr Foundation and The Irene E. & George A. Davis Foundation.

I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified
Spam
Offensive